Original Link: https://www.anandtech.com/show/527
MidiLand S4 8200 5.1 Speakers
by Jason Clark on April 12, 2000 12:27 AM EST- Posted in
- Smartphones
- Mobile
It seems like only yesterday when we were taking a look at the Midiland S4 7100 speakers. Three months after the S4 7100's were announced, the S4 8200's were introduced, and now, they are shipping. These new gems are an 8-piece system, which include a Dolby Digital Decoder, 5 satellites, 1 sub, and a remote control. The system is finished in a slick, metallic colour, which is quite different from the standard black/PC grey that we are used to.
DVD and PC have experienced a phenomenal growth over the past two years. With 5.1 channel sounds cards on the way into the mainstream market, things are changing for the audio side of the PC industry, and at an incredible rate. Along with this change has come the increase in demand for power and quality from computer speakers. Think back to when you could be content with a $30 set of LabTec speakers. Not any more -- gaming, MP3's, and DVD are changing all that. Now, when you go PC speaker shopping, you're lucky to get out of the store without spending US$70 minimum, and that's for a 3-channel system. This is not to say that the current price of speakers is unreasonable, but we are in a new era where high-wattage speakers with wall-shattering subs are becoming the norm. |
MidiLand is based out of Pomona, California. In 1990, they moved to San Dimas, California, incorporated the company, and became Midiland Inc. Today MidiLand has offices in the New Jersy, Netherlands, Germany, Taiwan. MidiLand has received many awards in the computer speaker industry, they are definitely one of the big players in this ever-changing market.
System Features
Specifications
RMS Power: | Total 200W Satellite 20W + 20W + 20W + 20W + 20W Subwoofer 100W |
Frequency Response: |
70Hz - 20kHz+3dB Satellites |
Drivers: | 3" Full range satellite speakers 6.5" Long excursion subwoofer |
Power Supply: | AC adapter |
S/N Ratio: | 92dB+3dB Satellites 105dB+3dB Subwoofer |
Function Controls: | Subwoofer-Power, volume, bass, LED power indicator Audio Digital Station (ADS-2000)-Power, test, mute, mode, enter Full-functional remote control |
Dimensions (WxHxD): | 4.61" x 4.72" x 4.53" Satellites 11.30" x 13.23" x 10.16" Subwoofer 7.10" x 2.40" x 5.30" ADS-2000 |
Dolby Digital & DTS
Currently, in the DVD market, we have two players: Dolby Digital and DTS (Digital Theatre Systems Digital Surround), with the major player being Dolby Digital. The main difference between the two is the bitrate. Dolby Digital's bitrate can be anywhere from 64 kbps to 448 kbps, while the bitrate for DTS can range from 64 kbps to 1536 kbps. Is the difference audible? That depends on with whom you talk. Some claim that DTS definitely sounds better, while others state that there really is no audible difference. DTS is getting some support from some major names in the film industry (i.e. DreamWorks Entertainment). DreamWorks Home Entertainment recently announced that we should expect to see DTS® Digital Surround DVD versions of several future DreamWorks releases. A well-written article on the differences and some DVD history can be found here: http://www.moviesoundpage.com/msp_dddtsdvd.htm.
ADS2000
Included with the S4 8200's is the ADS 2000. This control module, which MidiLand announced in March, is also compatible with the S4 7100 speakers. You won't find any volume knobs on this control module, so if you have some sort of a volume knob fetish, then these speakers are not for you. The control for the module is done with a remote control. MidiLand chose to go the Dolby Digital route in their control module, while VideoLogic added DTS to their control module. If you have ever seen the VideoLogic control module, it looks VERY similar to the ADS 2000. That's because the modules come from the same OEM. Big deal? Not really. The reason for not putting DTS into the ADS 2000 is probably because of price -- it's a separate decoder chip to decode DTS encoded audio tracks. As mentioned above, the major player is Dolby Digital and it's here to stay. Below is the break down on what the ADS 2000 does.
Volume
This can be adjusted for any/all channels (left, right, centre, rear right, rear left, sub).
Balance
This can be adjusted for any channel (left, right, centre, rear right, rear left, sub).
Delay
To change the delay effect, you can increase the delay effect for the rear speakers.Test
A simple test sequence that most 5.1 systems have, which plays some white noise to each individual channel.Bass
Turns the subwoofer on or off.Input
Selects form of input: digital/analog. Digital input is detected automatically.ProLogic
Turns ProLogic mode on or off.Surround
Turns surround mode on or off.Reset
Resets settings to factory defaults.
Sound Quality
Attention to detail was evident here. The most noticeable was the Subwoofer - it'll knock your socks off for its size. It's very clear and has extremely punchy bass. Your neighbours probably won't be quite as impressed as you will be :) The mid-range & treble are very similar to the S4 7100 speakers. Overall, a very well-rounded sound package.
Treble
Mid-range
The mid-range is provided by the same 3" woofer as for the treble. The treble and mid-range come together to provide a well-balanced, and very powerful, clear home-theatre level quality of sound.
MidiLand actually makes the woofers for their speakers (they have their own factory that builds them).
Subwoofer
The subwoofer is a 6.5" woofer enclosed in a very well constructed MDF (medium density fibreboard) cabinet. To say that this subwoofer is powerful is a severe understatement. The amount of bass that comes out of this relatively mid-sized cabinet is truly a work of engineering art. There isn't a need for a foot massager under your desk anymore; just set the sub under your desk and you can feel the movement of air quite nicely :)
Amplifier
MidiLand uses a Class AB amplifier, which includes separate amplification for each individual channel. This is pretty much a must for any high quality system. The amplifier puts out 200 Watts RMS. You will notice in the pictures that MidiLand included a fair amount of smoothing capacitance in the amplifier to ensure a consistent signal that won't fade when driven. There are five power supplies in all: 3 regulated and 2 unregulated. The 3 regulated power supplies have a total of 6800uF of smoothing capacitance, and the 2 unregulated power supplies have a total of 6800uf of smoothing capacitance. All in all, it's a well-constructed, solid amplifier. Rumour has it that MidiLand is looking into Class T amplifiers for future products. Class AB amplifiers are decent high fidelity amplifiers, but tend to be inefficient, sometimes losing 80% of their power through heat dissipation. Class T amplifiers bring the digital advantage to the audio amplification arena. Class T amplification actually decreases cost, as they do not require massive heat-sinks and power supplies because they are more efficient and do not produce as much heat as the typical Class AB amplifiers. Kudo's to MidiLand for keeping up with amplifier technology and thinking of ways to make systems more efficient and even produce higher quality audio.
Smoothing Capacitors |
Amplifier Inners |
Test System:
SoundBlaster Live (optical & S/PDIF tested)
Athlon 800
256MB Corsair PC133 Memory
Creative Annihilator PRO
Gaming
For the gaming tests, optical and S/PDIF were used. These speakers perform amazingly in gaming. The extremely powerful sub and clear, powerful satellites lend an incredible amount of realism to any game, especially 3D audio gaming.
When driving the Porsche 911 Turbo (in cockpit view) in Need For Speed: Porsche Unleashed, the sound was just incredible, from the sounds of the waterfalls passing down the right side of the car while doing 140mph to the silky sound of the 6-speed transmission going through its gears. It was non-stop realism.
Music
No matter what was being played through these speakers, audio was reproduced in a fantastic, clear, and powerful manner. Again, the most prominent part of these speakers is the subwoofer,
but the kind of sound you get out of the overall package is very similar to something 3-4 times its size. From the thunderous bass to the crisp, full mid-range and treble, this set of speakers is a serious competitor in the 5.1 PC speaker market.
Movies
Functionality
From the remote control to the ADS 2000, this package was well made and well thought out. The remote control, even when sitting right at your computer, is great when that nagging phone rings. MidiLand used standard speaker wire to connect the satellites to the amplifier, which is just as it should be, leaving the user the choice of wire lengths. Wire lengths were adequate; there were 3-10' lengths for the front speakers and 2-16' foot lengths for the rears. For those of you using this in a living room, you will probably want to go buy a roll of decent gauged wire, since 16' length is probably not enough. Some criticize speaker manufacturers for this, but let's be realistic - MidiLand, or any other company for that matter, do not keep the schematics for your living room on file :)
Inputs are plenty here. You have three choices in all: Digital SPDIF, Optical, and Analog RCA. The analog RCA in is a single L/R input. The ADS2000 will auto detect which input you are using. One thing was a little bit of an annoyance was that you can only have one digital input plugged in at the same time. You can have them both physically plugged in, but it will only use the digital sp/dif if the optical is plugged in at the same time. The ADS2000 also features four outputs, Line, Surround, Center, Subwoofer. Handy for hooking the decoder into other systems. Included on the rear of the subwoofer are the main volume controls for the system, which you may as well just turn almost right up, and control from the ADS2000.
Conclusion
MidiLand did a fantastic job on this 5.1 solution, from its metallic looking casing to the high quality audio that it reproduces. It's a 5.1 solution that will be hard to beat. The price is hard to beat as well, which can be found as low as US$292. It's priced very reasonably for what you get. Although Cambridge SoundWorks 2500's are cheaper, these don't pack anywhere near the same punch as the S4 8200's do, and don't have a remote control. If you are in the market for a set of 5.1 speakers, you should really take a look at these metallic gems.
For attention to detail, features galore, competitive price, and bass that packs an incredible punch, we award the MidiLand S4 8200's with the Gold Medal Award. |
How it Rates
|