Yeah I was thinking to myself when I clicked the link... it's either mechanical or it's not. It's a high end and (IMO) overpriced membrane keyboard. I might as well get a $15 Logitech membrane keyboard or spend a few extra dollars and get a real one. The only reason to buy one is if you spill Mountain Dew all over your keyboard constantly.
Mechanical linkage, membrane activation switch (as opposed to moving metal contacts). Same way the much sought-after IBM Model M works (though this Corsair board probably uses a plastic slip cam like the Cherry MX switches rather than a buckling spring + hammer). .
Know what else isn't a fully mechanical keyboard? The legendary IBM Model M's, the mechanical that so many people love. The buckling spring mechanisms just press down on a membrane underneath of them.
So while they'll have to prove themselves, I'll reserve judgement for now. Anandtech needs to do a complete teardown of this thing, the design of the switches should be interesting.
It's just a stream of water; you can see the water spout above it. They're demonstrating that it is water resistant. The fact that it has a membrane covering the PCB means that it's safe when you spill your Mountain Dew on it in the heat of the moment. Presumably you could also wash if off in the sink after it gets gummed up from your cheesy Doritos-dusted fingers and it would be just like new.
Sorry, but a membrane keyboard is not a mechanical keyboard no matter the sound of the keys. It's like attaching a huge wing to a neon. In the end, it's still not a sports car.
The point is that it actually feels like a mechanical keyboard, not just sounds like one (seriously, who would buy a membrane keyboard just to SOUND like a mechanical keyboard? Worst of both worlds...). The point is that for a cheaper price you can have something that actually functions similarly. He even said in the review that it feels pretty similar to the real thing. Maybe wait for a full review before assuming it's a bad idea.
I have my opinions and read the article, thank you very much. It's a crap keyboard that's only use is to spill your drink on it. It's not a mechanical keyboard in any sense of the word. I actually like the clicky sound so that's not a bad think IMO. If you like crappy membrane boards then by all means by this kb.
Great - then this keyboard isn't meant for you, I guess. It's meant for those who want the feel of mechanical with a cheaper cost.
But you don't know that "it's a crap keyboard" just because it isn't built the way you prefer. Why does it matter how the internals are designed if it works as intended? Considering you've never used the keyboard, I would say you really don't have a valid opinion here - or at least certainly not a valid enough one to make assumptions about its quality.
You're right. I never used that particular model. I stand by my opinion that it isn't even remotely mechanical in nature. I have four membrane keyboards in my possession. I still have my old Intel keyboard in a box. I keep it because it's built like a tank. Sure wish Intel didn't get out of the peripheral business. However, no matter how good the keyboard you can't duplicate the performance and feel of a mechanical switch. It took me only one time and I as typing considerably faster with the mechanical switches. I realize that people have different needs. I mean my primary concern was spilling soda all over my keyboard then I'd be all over this Cougar like a mature lady and a young buck. When my friend spilled beer on my Cherry keyboard, I unplugged it, rinsed it with tap water, shook off the excess water and let it air dry for a day. I was fine until it was completely drive because I had another Cherry keyboard that I used as a back up. I believe that they cost me $60 a piece.
No dedicated media keys, no thank you. That alt modifier garbage gets real old real fast when you are playing something and have to try and stretch your hand out and 2 key it, instead of just a tap.
In China, there are million of these "hybrid mechanical/fake mechanical" or "mechanical feeling". Marketing term is suck. Their price is about 10-25$. It is not mechanical at all.
We’ve updated our terms. By continuing to use the site and/or by logging into your account, you agree to the Site’s updated Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
20 Comments
Back to Article
Flunk - Tuesday, June 9, 2015 - link
Good to know that hybrid mechanical = not mechanical. Damn those marketing scumbags!The True Morbus - Tuesday, June 9, 2015 - link
Yep, I learned something useful today.Cool keyboard though, all things considered.
Alexvrb - Tuesday, June 9, 2015 - link
Yeah I was thinking to myself when I clicked the link... it's either mechanical or it's not. It's a high end and (IMO) overpriced membrane keyboard. I might as well get a $15 Logitech membrane keyboard or spend a few extra dollars and get a real one. The only reason to buy one is if you spill Mountain Dew all over your keyboard constantly.edzieba - Wednesday, June 10, 2015 - link
Mechanical linkage, membrane activation switch (as opposed to moving metal contacts). Same way the much sought-after IBM Model M works (though this Corsair board probably uses a plastic slip cam like the Cherry MX switches rather than a buckling spring + hammer). .Mr Perfect - Wednesday, June 10, 2015 - link
Know what else isn't a fully mechanical keyboard? The legendary IBM Model M's, the mechanical that so many people love. The buckling spring mechanisms just press down on a membrane underneath of them.So while they'll have to prove themselves, I'll reserve judgement for now. Anandtech needs to do a complete teardown of this thing, the design of the switches should be interesting.
ianmills - Tuesday, June 9, 2015 - link
Oh my god what's on the keyboard in the third image?! It looks like someone got a little too excited...Yuck!
WithoutWeakness - Tuesday, June 9, 2015 - link
It's just a stream of water; you can see the water spout above it. They're demonstrating that it is water resistant. The fact that it has a membrane covering the PCB means that it's safe when you spill your Mountain Dew on it in the heat of the moment. Presumably you could also wash if off in the sink after it gets gummed up from your cheesy Doritos-dusted fingers and it would be just like new.Eidigean - Tuesday, June 9, 2015 - link
Backslash key is in the wrong position... immediate non-starter for me.Mr Perfect - Wednesday, June 10, 2015 - link
Yeah, hopefully they have an ANSI layout board too.kurahk7 - Tuesday, June 9, 2015 - link
Can you guys also review the CM Storm Devastator? It's also a membrane keyboard that feels like a mechanical keyboard but is much cheaper.bigboxes - Tuesday, June 9, 2015 - link
Sorry, but a membrane keyboard is not a mechanical keyboard no matter the sound of the keys. It's like attaching a huge wing to a neon. In the end, it's still not a sports car.inighthawki - Tuesday, June 9, 2015 - link
The point is that it actually feels like a mechanical keyboard, not just sounds like one (seriously, who would buy a membrane keyboard just to SOUND like a mechanical keyboard? Worst of both worlds...). The point is that for a cheaper price you can have something that actually functions similarly. He even said in the review that it feels pretty similar to the real thing. Maybe wait for a full review before assuming it's a bad idea.bigboxes - Tuesday, June 9, 2015 - link
I have my opinions and read the article, thank you very much. It's a crap keyboard that's only use is to spill your drink on it. It's not a mechanical keyboard in any sense of the word. I actually like the clicky sound so that's not a bad think IMO. If you like crappy membrane boards then by all means by this kb.inighthawki - Wednesday, June 10, 2015 - link
Great - then this keyboard isn't meant for you, I guess. It's meant for those who want the feel of mechanical with a cheaper cost.But you don't know that "it's a crap keyboard" just because it isn't built the way you prefer. Why does it matter how the internals are designed if it works as intended? Considering you've never used the keyboard, I would say you really don't have a valid opinion here - or at least certainly not a valid enough one to make assumptions about its quality.
bigboxes - Wednesday, June 10, 2015 - link
You're right. I never used that particular model. I stand by my opinion that it isn't even remotely mechanical in nature. I have four membrane keyboards in my possession. I still have my old Intel keyboard in a box. I keep it because it's built like a tank. Sure wish Intel didn't get out of the peripheral business. However, no matter how good the keyboard you can't duplicate the performance and feel of a mechanical switch. It took me only one time and I as typing considerably faster with the mechanical switches. I realize that people have different needs. I mean my primary concern was spilling soda all over my keyboard then I'd be all over this Cougar like a mature lady and a young buck. When my friend spilled beer on my Cherry keyboard, I unplugged it, rinsed it with tap water, shook off the excess water and let it air dry for a day. I was fine until it was completely drive because I had another Cherry keyboard that I used as a back up. I believe that they cost me $60 a piece.meacupla - Tuesday, June 9, 2015 - link
a proper hybrid keyboard would be mechanical switches, but waterproof, or at the very least, water resistant.Mr Perfect - Wednesday, June 10, 2015 - link
*cough* Model M *cough*Sttm - Wednesday, June 10, 2015 - link
No dedicated media keys, no thank you. That alt modifier garbage gets real old real fast when you are playing something and have to try and stretch your hand out and 2 key it, instead of just a tap.abcslayer - Wednesday, June 10, 2015 - link
In China, there are million of these "hybrid mechanical/fake mechanical" or "mechanical feeling". Marketing term is suck. Their price is about 10-25$.It is not mechanical at all.
Mr Perfect - Wednesday, June 10, 2015 - link
What are the "switches" like? Just scissor switches like on laptops?